Yes, but I think your previous theory is also good. Guy is gay and can't risk getting caught as such because of his whole religious/family background and status as a football dude. That non-relationship with another homo posturing as a chick was very convenient and probably his best option, romance-wise. Same for the other dude.
Far from gay? You're not far from gay. You're only far from gay if you like the cock but force yourself not to think about it.
Think about the way you'd respond if Katie Couric put you on the spot like that. I'd point to that chick in the crowd and say "See that girl? She's giving me a boner. I'll fuck her right now on your set to make a point. Ms., do you wanna be fucked on TV?"
I'm exaggerating a tiny bit but you get my point. You would never answer "Faaaaaar from it." That's such a weird defensive answer.
Next he's gonna ask "Where's the proof? Where's the proof that I suck cock, eh? Y'all ain't got no proof, cause I don't tape that shit! So there!"