Hooligans Plays Baccarat

Does "Evil" Exist?

  • Start date
  • Replies
    105 Replies •
  • Views 7,641 Views

Cougar Bait

I Come Correct
Since
Jan 27, 2010
Messages
14,842
Score
93
Tokens
0
It's something I have thought about for quite some time. I love those shows on ID (Investigation Discovery) called Most Evil, about Serial Killers, their background, etc.

Dr. Stone made a "scale of evil" to determine what is the most evil. It is very interesting and it got me thinking (scary, I know). Does real "evil" exist? We can explain what we think are evil things by pointing to terrible acts and labeling it, but I am trying to define evil as a separate entity. Something that just exists. Would Ed Gein have done those terrible things regardless of his circumstance and upbringing or was he absolutely thrust into it because of his overbearing mother? I mean, I've read his biography. She was intent on not allowing him pre-marital sex and once may have pushed him down the stairs. Does that qualify as an upbringing that would most certainly lead to becoming a serial killer?

111974_f520.jpg


The list of things they found ole Ed involved in seems...well...hard to believe...

When police arrived at his Wisconsin farmhouse in the late ‘50s, they found a vast collection of meat art. In the woodshed of the farm was the naked, headless body of Bernice Worden, hanging upside down from a meat hook and slit open down the front. Her head and intestines were discovered in a box, her heart on a plate in the dining room. The skins from ten human heads were found preserved, and another skin taken from the upper torso of a woman was rolled up on the floor. There was a belt fashioned from carved-off nipples, a chair upholstered in human skin, the crown of a skull used as a soup-bowl, lampshades covered in flesh pulled taut, a table propped up by a human shinbones, and a refrigerator full of organs. The four posts on Gein’s bed were topped with skulls and a human head hung on the wall alongside nine death-masks – the skinned faces of women – and decorative bracelets made out of human skin. The stunned searchers also uncovered soup bowls fashioned from skulls, a shoebox full of female genitalia, faces stuffed with newspapers and mounted like hunting trophies on the walls, and a "mammary vest" flayed from the torso of a woman. Gein later confessed that he enjoyed dressing himself in this and other human-skin garments and pretending he was his own mother.

Isn't that "Evil?"
 
Last edited:
Some years back when I used to drink'n'drug heavily, I became very depressive and I got very interested in psycho killers. Mildly obsessed for a time. I would read books and watch various Bill Kurtis shows and I knew all the names and stats and was ready to debate anyone dopey enough to think Charles Manson was in the same league as any of the "greats."

Is there "evil"? I don't know. There is some fucked up shit out there, I know that.

Well actually, I will say yes, evil exists.
 
One person's evil may be another person's version of acceptable behaviour so I think it's hard to rationalize the existence of something so subjective. Millions of people feel Hitler was evil yet there are others who were willing to die because they believed in what he was doing and still defend him to this day.

I think there are people who are definitely considered messed up by the majority of the first world population but that to me is a product of brain chemistry and their social environment to a certain extent. Not because of some ingrained sense of 'evilness'.
 
Ficshy, Nina's statement does belong when you consider Sharis statement. If as in what Shari said it's a matter of perspective or more directly personal opinion of what is good and what is evil then it applies. If a person BELIEVES in good then they also BELIEVE in evil.

Sociological and philosophical debate because no-one can put concrete evidence of what constitutes evil. I would tell you someone who can rape or murder a child is pure evil while someone else will argue they are simply sick.